Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

Post a reply


BBCode is ON
[img] is ON
[url] is ON
Smilies are OFF

Topic review
   

If you wish to attach one or more files enter the details below.

Maximum filesize per attachment: 3 MiB.

Expand view Topic review: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » August 9, 2025, 5:03 pm

The James Norris was smashed against the loading pier of the then St. Lawrence Cement Company (now Holcim Canada) dock at Colborne, Ontario on Lake Ontario. The winds shifted to the northwest on the evening of November 11, 1995, and while the partially-loaded Norris tried to depart the dock to wait out the storm out on the lake, the stern was thrown against a caisson where a 12-foot hole was punched in the Norris' hull, port side aft. Water flooded into the engine and boiler rooms and the Norris soon settled to her spar deck with a heavy list to port in 32 feet of water.

The Norris was re-floated a week later by salvage crews from McKeil Marine and she was placed on the drydock at Port Weller by November 21st.

https://images.maritimehistoryofthegrea ... 63/page/16

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Chief1 » August 9, 2025, 6:39 am

Thank you and great images of the casualty -always can count on resident historians on this great site.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » August 8, 2025, 4:26 pm

algowest wrote: August 8, 2025, 12:26 pm Algobay/Montrealais collision was June 25, 1980
I remember this accident well as I had just moved to the area (Algonac) a few months earlier and though I was only 11 years old at the time I can still recall the badly damaged bow section of the Montrealais following its early morning collision in fog with the Algobay abreast St. Clair, Michigan and Courtright, Ontario. I saw it on the evening of the accident after it had been towed down the St. Clair River to just below Recor Point and anchored for the night in the usual anchorage area for ships awaiting dock space at the Detroit Edison St. Clair Power Plant (I don't believe the Belle River Plant was operational yet at the time). The ship was moored with its stern facing the current which undoubtedly was done to reduce stress on the damaged bow. I have attached two photographs from my collection that show the damaged Montrealais at what I believe is in the anchorage I described earlier.
Attachments
PP0817_TN_LOWRES.jpg
PP0816_TN_LOWRES.jpg

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by algowest » August 8, 2025, 12:26 pm

Algobay/Montrealais collision was June 25, 1980

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Denny » August 8, 2025, 1:54 am

Chief1 to answer your question on what year the Montrealais and Algobay hit each other in the fog on the St. Clair River, it was in 1980. There’s photos of the damage to both vessels here on this site. Just look up the Fleet Photo Gallery and look through the list for the Montrealais which later was sold and renamed Algoma Montrealais and eventually scrapped overseas. The Algobay was rebuilt in China with a new forebody and later was renamed Radcliffe R. Latimer to which she still is sailing today. Another vessel I just thought about and would like to add to this list is the 1,000 footer the Edwin H. Gott. In February 1979, the Gott departed from Milwaukee on their maiden voyage at that time. It was the earliest or latest ever maiden voyage by a lake freighter. As the Gott crossed into Lake Superior, they encountered one of if not the worst ever years of frozen ice on Lake Superior! The Gott received major damage to its ballast tanks from the ice crossing Lake Superior upon their arrival in Two Harbors. They did not get repairs done and completed until Spring 1979 thus, they did not load at Two Harbors either until Spring as well. The point is, the damage the Gott received on her trip across Lake Superior definitely could have been far and much worse and it could have easily ended her career before it ever begun! Two other USS/GLF fleet vessels the Callaway and the Munson also were involved in the same crossing as the Gott was and both of those two steamers and vessels also received major damage from the ice as did the original icebreaker Mackinaw as well!

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Chief1 » August 7, 2025, 9:22 pm

What year did the Montrealis hit the Algoma vessel in the fog near downtown St Lair, Mich.? And mentioned below the Str. Middletown with the missing rudder did indeed lay up in Lorain, but repairs were done in Port Weller shipyard that spring. She was towed by 2 G-Tugs to that Canadian yard with the rudder welded to the No. 5 cargo hold tank top

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Denny » August 4, 2025, 1:22 pm

In adding more information to this thread here’s a few more vessels that have survived major accidents and have gone on and continued sailing after their accidents. One that comes to mind happened just a few short years ago in the Welland Canal and you can see and view this incident on You Yube Video. Does anyone remember or recall when the Florence Spirit collided with the saltwater vessel Alanis? Both ships scraped each other good and each had to be drydocked for major repairs. The Florence Spirit made it on her own to Sturgeon Bay to get repairs done to her and luckily she still fails today. The Alanis I believe was drydocked at Port Weller for their repair work. Both ships at the time of the collision were fully loaded. The Alanis had wind towers for Duluth and they still sail today. Florence Spirit I think unloaded their cargo then left in ballast for Sturgeon Bay and BayShip to get repairs done to her there. There’s been several times when ships have hit the Seawall in Port Huron at the Blue Watet Bridge causing damage to the Seawall. One was a Russian ship the Admital Ushakov which survived that accident and later continued to sail for a time. Another occurred in 1994 which involved I believe it was Canadian Ranger back then hitting the wall at Port Huron and causing considerable damage to the Sea Wall itself. The ship survived that accident and later continued to sail for many more seasons after that. These are just a few more accidents involving some ships that come to mind. Hope that my information I provided here has helped out. Also, not 100% sure but the accident in 1994 in Port Huron at the Seawall involved either the Admital Ushakov or Canadian Ranger not sure which it is?

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » August 1, 2025, 5:45 pm

Guest wrote: July 31, 2025, 7:40 am [There is a photograph of the Beeghly sitting on the bottom alongside a dock at Duluth following this incident that occurred on December 22, 1978, that appears in the March/April 1979 issue of GLMI's Telescope publication that is available for viewing online. Outbound at the time it hit the breakwater, the crew managed to get the Beeghly back into the harbor before settling in shallow water. The photo definitely shows the ship sitting much deeper in the water than normal and it appears fortunate that it managed to return into harbor rather than settling into deeper waters.
Here's the issue of Telescope with the Charles M. Beeghly after it hit the breakwall in Duluth on December 22, 1978. Look for page 54: https://images.maritimehistoryofthegrea ... 27301T.PDF

BTW, the Beeghly was damaged in a grounding at Johnson Point turn on January 26, 1978 and sank in the channel.

Also in 1978, the John Sherwin snagged the ice boom near Sault Ste. Marie at Mission Point, suffering bottom and propeller damage. That occurred on December 13, 1978.

A week before that, Middletown lost her rudder out on Lake Michigan and had to be towed to Great Lakes Steel in Detroit for unloading, then went to AmShip Lorain for repairs.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by ashland69 » August 1, 2025, 5:30 pm

Another candidate for suffering a major accident and sailing again was the Donnacona of Canada Steamship Lines in 1964. The Donnacona was built by the Western Dry Dock & Shipbuilding Co. of Port Arthur, Ontario, and launched as W. Grant Morden on April 14, 1914. CSL was less than a year old when the company took delivery of the 190.50 metre long vessel. The first cargo was iron ore taken aboard at Escanaba, Michigan, for delivery to Port Colborne. Setting Great Lakes cargo records was common in the early years and included 760,066 bushels of oats in 1915, 504,908 bushels of wheat in 1916, 14,955 tons of iron ore in 1928 and a world record 587,844 bushels of barley taken aboard on April 30, 1947. CSL changed the name to Donnacona in 1926 and the ship continued regular service on the upper four Great Lakes. On Aug. 27, 1932, the ship made its first trip down the newly opened Welland Canal, opening Lake Ontario ports, particularly Kingston, as a destination.

A fire disabled the ship in Lake Huron on Dec. 16, 1964, before an SOS could be sent out. The blaze did serious damage to the wheelhouse and forward cabins and these were replaced at Windsor over the winter of 1964-1965. Donnacona last operated in 1968 and laid up at Midland. Following a sale to Spanish ship breakers, the ship raised steam one last time and came down the Welland Canal under her own power on June 14, 1969. A week later, it was taken in tow at Quebec City and delivered to Bilbao, Spain, on July 12 for dismantling.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Chief1 » August 1, 2025, 12:39 am

Oh and one more - the downbound ARTHUR B HOMER ( Bethlehem Steel fleet) getting smacked head on by the “Pilot-less” Greek Salty NAVISHIPPER in the Fighting Island channel Detroit River. It was during a work stoppage by the Pilots Assoc. and the salty left Toledo without one, almost made it.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 31, 2025, 7:40 am

Guest wrote: July 30, 2025, 11:40 am Charles M. Beeghley sinking in Duluth Harbor, circa 1978/79 after hitting the breakwater. Surprisingly I've never been able to find a picture of this incident on line. I believe the Beeghley had another major incident a year or two later.

Also, the E.M. Ford sinking in Milwaukee and later returned to service - courtesy of the insurance settlement.
There is a photograph of the Beeghly sitting on the bottom alongside a dock at Duluth following this incident that occurred on December 22, 1978, that appears in the March/April 1979 issue of GLMI's Telescope publication that is available for viewing online. Outbound at the time it hit the breakwater, the crew managed to get the Beeghly back into the harbor before settling in shallow water. The photo definitely shows the ship sitting much deeper in the water than normal and it appears fortunate that it managed to return into harbor rather than settling into deeper waters.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 30, 2025, 11:40 am

Charles M. Beeghley sinking in Duluth Harbor, circa 1978/79 after hitting the breakwater. Surprisingly I've never been able to find a picture of this incident on line. I believe the Beeghley had another major incident a year or two later.

Also, the E.M. Ford sinking in Milwaukee and later returned to service - courtesy of the insurance settlement.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 28, 2025, 9:53 pm

The Eugene J. Buffington was severely damaged in a grounding at Boulder Reef in June 1942 and required a major salvage effort to re-float and strengthen her hull for the trip to the shipyard at South Chicago. If it wasn't for the demand for iron ore due to World War 2, the Buffington may very well have been scrapped.

The Algosoo fire occurred in March 1986 and damaged the conveyor belts, and aft accommodation area. Repairs took several months to complete.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Denny » July 28, 2025, 3:18 pm

Yes they did while laid up once in Port Colborne. Thanks also to Algowest for reminding us of the Algowood incident. Another one that I had forgotten about and didn’t think of! Speaking of hill buckling, many years ago remember the Beechglen also had its hill buckle as well while they were unloading I think in Cardinal, Ontario? They were later repaired and returned to service.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 28, 2025, 9:08 am

Didn't Algosoo have her stern quarters burned out also?

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by algowest » July 28, 2025, 7:56 am

One that comes to mind is Algowood hull buckled, on June 1, 2000 at Bruce Mines, Ontario. This accident occurred during cargo loading. Hull bracing was added & Wood was towed to Port Weller for repairs and adding 10’ hull length to new Seawaymax length limit

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 27, 2025, 8:56 pm

The Cason J. Callaway was severely damaged in a collision with the B. F. Jones in the lower St. Mary's River on August 21, 1955.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Denny » July 27, 2025, 6:31 pm

How about this one boatnerds. Anyone remember when this one from the 1990s decade occurred? The former Kinsmsn Independent when she had grounded off of or near Isle Royale. She was I thought way off course for some reason and she grounded on some rocks or something up there? It caused extensive damage to her however, she survived for many more years and seasons and she also had two more owners in her career Voyageur Marine and also later on the Lower Lakes fleet. I think there are stories about her in previous editions of the KYS books and photos also. Roger since he once sailed on her I’m sure recalls the incident with her off and near Isle Royale for certain!

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Jared » July 27, 2025, 5:30 pm

I think the sinking, raising, and refurbishing of the George Humphrey in 1945-46 is a amazing story. She spent two years on the bottom in deep water.

The stern half of the William C Moreland being raised and returned to service while it's bow remains sunk off Sawtooth Reef is another example. The Maderia has her bow sunk in Lake Erie and her stern is sunk on Lake Huron 20 years apart.

The Maatafa, Howard M Hanna Jr, and LC Waldo in 1905 and 1913 are good reads too.

Re: Ships that Survived Major Accidents to Sail Again

by Guest » July 27, 2025, 4:45 pm

Chief1 wrote: July 26, 2025, 9:55 pm M/v Walter J McCarthy backed into the Hallet dock slip in Superior one lay up ripping a hole in the stern and flooded the entire engine room.
The Pringle fleets m/v Paul Thayer a month after the Fitz went down grounded at Southeast Shoals tearing her fwd 1/3 of her bottom out, repaired at Toledo yard. The steamer Detroit Edison grounded so severely in Grays Reef that she never did sail again.
That's actually incorrect about the Detroit Edison. It was laidup at Bay Shipbuilding in late December 1980 after it was towed from Charlevoix where temporary repairs had been made. Detroit Edison was repaired, though the repairs were extensive (five tanks ripped open) and costly and she sailed in 1981 and part of 1982 when she was laidup at Sturgeon Bay alongside the Roger Blough.

Top